Posted by Bone at May 22nd, 2006
I’m probably not the most environmentally friendly guy out there, but I don’t particularly like the idea of destroying the planet so I do subscribe to the Treehugger RSS feed.
Today they posted an article about a UK based mobile phone recycling company called envirofone who will give you money in return for your old mobile phone, and will then send it to a part of the world where they don’t need the latest technology (because, y’know, I use the videophone capabilities of my phone every day….) and will also donate some money to a charity on your behalf.
Seemed like a pretty good deal, and much better than just leaving a phone in a drawer for years, or worse, throwing it in the bin, so I thought I’d check it out. I’ve been at university for 3 years now, and I’m onto my 3rd phone, so I don’t really need my old t610 or k700i. I inputted both phones into the interface (very easy) and was given some options as to how I could be rewarded for saving the planet (as if that wasn’t enough). I should have probably mentioned that envirofone have teamed up with Argos, and you can get credit with them rather than cold hard cash. For comparison I’ve done some simple eBay economics so that you can see how the deal compares.
T610: Cash value = £11.98
Argos credit = £13.78
Sample eBay auction = £19.50 + £4.50 postage (with over an hour remaining, and with the phone locked to Orange, like me)
So it doesn’t seem like an astounding deal in terms of money, but it certainly is simple, and my t610 certainly wouldn’t reach the same value as my eBay sample, since mine is beaten up and envirofone don’t seem too concerned about the phones condition.
k700i
Cash value = £14.92
Argos credit = £17.92
Sample eBAy auction = Lots of phones with more than 30mins left on the auction that were well over £35, some reaching £60
This one seems like an even worse deal, considering that the cash value is around 25% of what is achievable with a well design eBay auction. Again, my k700i wouldn’t reach these prices as it had a year of student usage. My current phone, a k600i would get me £30, which isn’t bad, but I presume that by the time I finish with it in November it will be worth £15ish again.
So its a very promising system, and you can’t really expect it to compete with eBay, since they’re a company that are sending the recycled phones out all over the world to help others, and are giving part of your money to a charity. I guess it just comes down to how selfish you are… or lazy.